Tchaikovsky: The Final Years (Brown, David//Tchaikovsky) Review

Tchaikovsky: The Final Years (Brown, David//Tchaikovsky)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
I've read the first three volumes of this most extensive and thoroughly researched monumental biography. I can't wait to read this final fourth volume. I have found only two faults, so far. The author delves into great detail and depth about all of the master's music. This should be welcome reading to those unfamiliar with certain neglected works. However, he allows too much of his own personal opinion to taint his descriptions of certain works (certainly stemming from his British egotistical, "know-it-all" background). I don't fault him personally, as much as recognize his country of origin in every paragraph! One perfect example is his total dismissal of the Piano Sonata in G, as being one of the dullest works Tchaikovsky composed. Having performed the work myself, and heard such exciting performances as those of Richter, and others, I can only assume Brown's only knowledge of the piece is from hearing a "dull" British pianist's performance. But, for me, the more unforgivable fault is the author's inability to come to terms with Tchaikovsky's homosexuality. Mr. Brown obviously has difficulty with this topic, and refers to it as "Tchaikovsky's condition." Mr. Brown really belongs to Tchaikovsky's era (he's way out of touch) in terms of his ability to understand it. Too bad, as it really casts a shadow over this otherwise outstanding series. I'm quite convinced that Tchaikovsky should be held up as a hero for his ability to acknowledge his sexual orientation to the extent he could in such an oppresive environment! Also, remember that the Soviets for years suppressed any homosexual references in Tchaikovsky's letters and writings. Thus, he actually did acknowledge it to a far greater extent then was previously known. His stature should gain by this. He was a remarkable man deserving everyone's respect and admiration for the hours of pleasure he has brought to the world!

Click Here to see more reviews about: Tchaikovsky: The Final Years (Brown, David//Tchaikovsky)



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Tchaikovsky: The Final Years (Brown, David//Tchaikovsky)

0 comments:

Post a Comment